Disc vs. Rim Brakes

What are disc brakes?

Let us begin with the basics. A disc brake is a caliper with a pad that clamps down on either side of a rotor. When you squeeze your brakes, the pads contact the rotors, causing friction and slowing you down.

You can find the calipers at either the front or the rear of the bike and mount them using a threaded axle, which you screw onto your fork. Disc brakes often have mechanical, cable, or hydraulic drive systems.

What are rim brakes?

On the other hand, rim brakes are a braking type that uses rubber pads that clamp onto your wheel's rims. It creates friction between the pads and the rims to stop your bike.

Rim brakes come in different types, including cantilever, V-brake, and V-brake, with a rear hub. You can find these brakes on the front or rear wheel or even the disc brake models with a corresponding rear wheel.

The cantilever type uses one brake pad and one brake rotor, while the V-brake uses two pads (one each for the front and rear wheel) and two rotors. The V-brake with a hub has both front and rear brakes.

Disc vs. rim brakes: What are the differences?

With the basic knowledge of the two, let us narrow down the ultimate factors that stand the disc and rim brakes apart.

1. Braking power
Regarding stopping power, disc brakes are much more powerful than rim brakes.

The power from the brake pads is distributed evenly on both wheels, with disc brakes capable of applying up to four times more force than rim brakes.

Rim brakes also stop slower because they have a smaller rotor surface area. They take longer to cool down compared to a typical disc brake pad. Here is a system where the front and rear rotors work together efficiently.

2. Weight
Due to the larger rotor surface area of the disc brakes, you can find that they are heavier than rim brakes. The additional weight might be a nuisance for people who ride on rough roads, but it's also an advantage if you have a performance-oriented bike.

Rim brakes are almost as heavy as disc brakes but are much easier to carry since they only require two wheels. Also, rim brakes will give you more control over your bike because they don't create any sliding that could cause accidents.

3. Cost
Rim brakes are cheaper and more affordable than disc brakes since they are less advanced.

The price difference is because of an additional rotor and brake pad for disc and rim brakes, which means that you'll have to shell out more money for discs when compared to rim brakes.

Plus, removing a disc requires a few extra steps compared to removing a rim brake—a task that is often much easier to do with a set of pliers.

4. Weather conditions
Wet or muddy conditions can spell disaster for both disc and rim brakes. Disc brakes are more efficient because they work great with less rotor clearance.

On the other hand, rim brakes are at a disadvantage regarding the weather conditions. They take forever to dry off after getting wet or muddy and can be difficult to clean because of the tiny spaces between the pads and rims.

As a result, you need great patience and some extra time to set up your rim brakes again. But then again, this is true for brake mechanisms that get wet, like V-brakes and cantilevers.

5. Rim wear
Wears are inevitable. But disc brakes have a longer life span than rim brakes.

Rim brakes are notorious for wearing down the rims, which can cause your wheel to freewheel. Disc brakes, however, don't wear down the rims because they don't need to rub against anything.

If you are worried about rotors wearing down too quickly, you should know that they're already made of high-quality steel and that there's a possibility of re-shaping or replacing them if worn out.

6. Maintenance
Rim brakes are better off than disc brakes when it comes to maintenance.Here are some reasons why:
 
a. Rim brakes require less time for maintenance - only about 20 minutes on average. They don't require major overhauls or special tools outside regular cleaning and re-lubricating cable or brake pads.
 
b. Rim brakes are easier to adjust than disc brakes since they don't have bulky calipers that make fine adjustments hard to do with a normal wrench set. Closer inspection and minor adjustments can be made without removing the bike's wheels.

c. Disc brakes have routine maintenance that requires removing the wheel and a couple of steps in between - such as removing the disc brake pads, adjusting their tension, and re-lubricating the cable. Then there's also the job of cleaning up any extra brake dust.

It's hard to remove the pads and wheels because they're screwed onto your bike and most likely installed with matching lug nuts, which are practically impossible to remove without special tools.

Pros of disc brakes

You should be aware of these notable benefits of disc brakes before deciding which braking system is best for you. Here are the pros of disc brakes:

1. Consistent performance
With disc brakes, the power distributed evenly across the two wheels provides smooth and consistent stopping power. You don't have to squeeze your brakes too hard to get the most performance.

2. Disc brakes are less weather-dependent than rim brakes
Disc brakes perform well in wet or muddy conditions because no pads are rubbing against the rims, making them easier to maintain than rim breaks in these weather conditions.

3. Improved heat dissipation
The rotor on disc brakes is exposed and larger than the rims on rim brakes, so they can dissipate heat faster when used in stops. The braking power will stay consistent even if riding in hot conditions or using heavy braking power.

4. Easy to adjust
The quick-release mechanism of disc brakes allows you to adjust the amount of brake power outputted by lifting and turning the lever. It will immediately release the pads from the rotor, so they won't fall back onto the wheels and cause unnecessary brake squeals.

5. No jamming
This benefit results from a solid connection between the rotor and the caliper assembly on disc brakes. Because there is no need for the Caliper assembly to press against rims, there's no risk of derailment or jamming caused by a lack of contact between brake pads and rims.

Cons of disc brakes

Some of the drawbacks of using disc brakes include:

1. Costly
Components of the disc brake setup, such as the brake pads and brake rotors, are expensive. That is why disc brakes are more expensive than rim brakes.

2. Maintenance
The amount of time required to maintain disc brakes is sometimes a bother to most bikers because they require you to remove and adjust the entire wheel assembly with special tools, which is less convenient than it may seem at first glance.

3. Less aerodynamic
Disc discs have a wider rotor and caliper assembly on the wheel, which causes disc brakes to have less aerodynamic properties than rims brakes. It is more challenging to obtain good aerodynamics with discs because of their larger size and exposed rotors.

Pros of rim brakes

With rim brakes, you can enjoy the benefits listed below:

1. Simple to install and maintain
An average user can install and maintain rim brakes by keeping the cables in good shape and refilling the brake fluid with a quality brand at every oil change.

2. Inexpensive
Rim brakes are significantly cheaper than disc brakes because they don't require additional hardware and special tools to install. They're also lighter because they don't include metal rotor assemblies or new brake pads to wear out quickly.

3. More aerodynamic
Rim brakes are more aerodynamic than disc brakes, so if you're willing to give up a few grams of weight for improved performance, rim break might be the best choice.

Cons of rim brakes

Rim brakes on your bike have these limitations.

1. Quick wears
The pads in the rim brakes wear out after a few months of regular use. It would be best to replace them now and then to get the most out of your braking system.

2. Limits on tire size and rim width
Rim brakes work with specific tire sizes and rim widths. It would help to correctly position the brake calipers to ensure proper contact between the brake pads and the rim. If the tire or rim deviates from the specified size or width range, it may not fit properly within the brake calipers, compromising braking performance.

3. Limited braking distance
Rim brakes have less power than disc brakes but also have to endure greater distances due to their slow-starting moments when applied against fast-moving vehicles or sudden stops from top speed.

How to choose disc brakes and rim brakes

When debating between disc brakes and rim brakes, there are key points that you might want to pay attention to, which include:

1. Performance
Disc brakes certainly beat rim brakes in both braking distance and braking power. Because of their wider rotors and caliper assemblies, they will provide better stopping performance than rim brakes at the cost of more weight.

2. Cost
Disc brakes are more expensive, but this is expected because you need to replace the brake pads from the first use, which requires replacement parts incompatible with disc brake mounting hardware.

3. Size or weight
Disc brakes are bigger and heavier than rim brakes, but this is a fair trade-off for improved stopping power in exchange for greater weight and bulk that must be lugged around on long trips.

4. Riding terrain
The environment you encounter on the road will determine your choice of brakes. Suppose you regularly ride in wet or muddy conditions. In that case, consider using disc brakes because they operate effectively in these types of terrain, unlike rim brakes that can stick to rims under these conditions.

Because brake pads on rim brakes don't come in contact with the rims and are relatively inexpensive to replace, they're a better choice for dry roads.

5. Frame and fork compatibility
The bicycle frame and fork must be compatible with the braking you want. You will have to ensure that your bike's frame and forks are designed for rim brakes or disc brakes.

6. Ease of adjustment and maintenance
Brakes on your bike should be as easy as possible to adjust and maintain, especially if you're a novice rider unfamiliar with brake adjustments and maintenance.

If you can't spend a lot of time trying to figure out how to adjust or maintain your bicycle's brakes, then the rim might be the best option for you because it's much easier to arrange components when there is no need for special tools that are required when using disc brakes.

7. Road safety
If safety is a major concern, consider using disc brakes due to their more stopping power than rim brakes. Rim brakes are known to squeal and are generally less reliable than disc brakes.

8. Comfort
If comfort carries lots of weight, you might choose rim brakes because they are lighter and have less mass than disc brakes.

However, this preference for comfort should be balanced with safety factors and wheel size, tire width, and frame size so that the bike will fit your body type well.

Conclusion

The decision between rim brakes and disc brakes is personal based on the factors listed above. The content has laid out most of the knowledge you need before purchasing the right braking system for your bike.

Related Articles

【Value Road Tyres】
https://santic.com/blogs/extra/value-road-tyres


【Bike Racks】
https://santic.com/blogs/extra/bike-racks


【Best Gravel Bike Pedals】
https://santic.com/blogs/extra/best-gravel-bike-pedals


【Best Mountain Bike Pedals】
https://santic.com/blogs/extra/mountain-bike-pedals


【Best Road Bike Saddles】
https://santic.com/blogs/extra/best-road-bike-saddles

Cycling Gear Selection

Santic Milo Women's jersey

Santic Malena Women's Fall Jersey

Santic Basquiat Road Shoes

Subscribe for Newsletter

The latest news, events and stories delivered right to your inbox